Those not in the labor force hit a record number in the last month. While the mainstream press tries to spin it as a retirement trend, the reality is mostAmericans are too broke to retire. The Atlanta Fed added some color to explain the big decline in labor force participation. As it turns out, the decline is coming from structurally problematic areas. We have many that are in the prime-age category (25 to 54 years of age) that simply say they don’t want a job. There is also a big jump in those on disability beyond normal population growth. And finally, we have a larger share of younger Americans going to college and loading up on mega amounts of student debt. Another contributing factor that is nicely left out is that we have many older Americans continuing to work into old age because as we have mentioned, many older Americans are too broke to retire. Let us look at the research more closely.
Not in the labor force and not wanting a job
What is probably more troubling about the growth in the “not in the labor force” category is that a big jump has come from those 25 to 54 years of age. This is the prime 30 year window when Americans typically work. Yet something is dramatically shifting. While the labor force participation rate of older Americans is holding steady, the rate of those in the prime-age range has collapsed.
The collapse of the labor force participation rate of those 25 to 54 years of age goes completely against the mainstream narrative. Take a look at the trend:
The group leading the way lower is coming from the group that should be working. There is now a deeper attempt to explain this rate decline beyond the party line that Americans are simply getting older and are taking their non-existent retirement nest egg into the sunset. That is not the case. Half of elderly Americans would be out on the street without Social Security.
So what is driving the rate lower?
Source: Atlanta Fed
“(Atlanta Fed) The decrease in labor force participation among prime-age individuals has been driven mostly by the share who say they currently don’t want a job. As of December 2014, prime-age labor force participation was 2.4 percentage points below its prerecession average. Of that, 0.5 percentage point is accounted for by a higher share who indicate they currently want a job; 2 percentage points can be attributed to a higher share who say they currently don’t want a job.”
While the aging of the population is a factor (of course) there are other categories that are pushing the rate lower. Let us go through them one by one:
Prime age – want a job: This is the most obvious one. These are people that want a job but are simply not counted. Many of the long term unemployed fall in this category.
Prime-age –don’t want a job: This is an odd category and accounts for a large number of Americans not in the labor force. You can have folks that were so exhausted at looking for work that they simply have given up.
Schooling amount the young: We have a record number of Americans in college and we also have $1.36 trillion in student debt outstanding. While an education is important, what is the true value of going to college and how do you choose when there are nearly 5,000 universities and colleges? What about those that get sucked into for-profit paper mills?
Age-adjusted disability: What is interesting in this category is that we have seen a high jump in this group adjusting for population growth. In other words, we are seeing more people claiming disability beyond the actual expected growth in the population.
Later retirement: This one obviously goes against the media squawking. More Americans are working later into life because they simply don’t have the means to retire.
Aging of the population: This is the baby boomer party line here.
In other words, the big drop in labor force participation is happening largely because of weak performance in the economy, not old people cashing out and heading into Margaritaville.